Skip to content

State comparison · Updated 2026

Colorado vs. New Mexico elk hunting.

Colorado's giant herd and over-the-counter access against New Mexico's two quirks: a pure random draw with no point creep, and a landowner-voucher market that sells guaranteed tags. Head to head on odds, access, and cost.

Hunt Colorado at Elk GladeAll elk states ranked

Head to head

Colorado and New Mexico, side by side.

DimensionColoradoNew Mexico
Elk herd~280,000 — largest on Earth~70,000
Nonresident tagsOTC available (archery, 2nd/3rd rifle) + limited entryDraw, outfitter-allocation, or landowner voucher
Point systemPreference points; OTC needs noneNONE — pure random draw every year
Guaranteed accessOTC tags you can buy outrightLandowner vouchers (paid) guarantee a tag
Time to huntCan hunt this year via OTCRandom draw each year, or buy a voucher
Famous unitsGMU 201 + the limited high-country unitsThe Gila, the Valle Vidal, units 15/16
Public land~23M acresLarge blocks but less than CO; voucher hunts often private
Best forOpportunity, this-year hunts, big herdHunters who hate point creep, or will buy a voucher

The honest verdict

Colorado for the herd; New Mexico to escape point creep.

Colorado is the higher-opportunity state by a wide margin — four times the elk and over-the-counter tags you can buy and hunt this year. For most hunters it’s the simpler, surer path.

New Mexico’s draw is the appeal. With no preference or bonus points, every year is a fresh, equal-odds shot — no decade-long points arms race. And if you don’t want to gamble at all, the landowner-voucher market sells guaranteed tags. New Mexico rewards hunters who’d rather take a clean annual chance (or pay for certainty) than grind points.

Want the biggest herd and the easiest tag? Colorado — the country Elk Glade guides on GMU 59.

Frequently asked

Colorado vs New Mexico questions.

Is Colorado or New Mexico better for elk hunting?

Colorado has roughly four times New Mexico's elk (~280,000 vs ~70,000) and sells over-the-counter tags, making it the higher-opportunity choice for most hunters. New Mexico's appeal is its draw structure: it uses a pure random draw with NO preference or bonus points, so every applicant has the same odds every year regardless of history — and its strong landowner-voucher market lets you buy guaranteed access. Choose Colorado for the bigger herd and OTC ease; choose New Mexico if you hate point creep or want to buy a voucher.

Does New Mexico have a preference point system for elk?

No — and that's New Mexico's signature feature. New Mexico uses a pure random draw with no preference or bonus points. A first-time applicant has the same odds as someone who's applied for twenty years. For hunters frustrated by the point-creep arms race in Colorado, Wyoming, Utah, and Arizona, New Mexico's every-year-is-a-fresh-shot system is a real draw.

What are New Mexico landowner elk vouchers?

New Mexico has a robust landowner-voucher (sometimes called 'authorization' or EPLUS) system in which private landowners receive transferable elk tags they can sell. Buying a voucher gives a nonresident a guaranteed tag without entering the random draw — you pay for certainty. It's one of the most accessible ways to secure a New Mexico elk hunt, and it supports a whole outfitter-and-voucher marketplace.

Which has more elk, Colorado or New Mexico?

Colorado has far more — roughly 280,000 elk versus New Mexico's approximately 70,000. Colorado holds the largest elk population of any state. New Mexico's herd is smaller but includes some excellent, lightly-pressured units like the Gila and the Valle Vidal that produce quality bulls.

Is New Mexico good for a guaranteed elk hunt?

Yes, via the landowner-voucher market. Because New Mexico has no point system, the random draw is a gamble every year — but buying a landowner voucher sidesteps the draw entirely and guarantees a tag. For a nonresident who wants certainty about hunting a given year, New Mexico's voucher system is one of the most reliable paths in the West, though it adds cost.

Pillar

All states ranked

Eight elk states compared.

Comparison

Colorado vs Utah

The trophy-state matchup.

Hunt

Colorado outfitter

Guided GMU 59 elk at Elk Glade.