Skip to content

Season-by-season · Updated 2026-05-28

When to hunt Colorado elk.

Six seasons, different tradeoffs. The trophy season, the rut season, the highest-success season, the lowest-pressure season. Pick by your goal — we've put hunters through every one.

Plan a huntGMU 59 unit profile

The short answer

It depends on your goal. For trophy bulls, mid-November rifle 3rd. For peak rut excitement, September archery. For highest success rate, rifle 2nd or 3rd on private land. For lowest hunter pressure, muzzleloader or rifle 4th. The six Colorado elk seasons each optimize for something different. The decision matrix below maps goals to seasons.

Decision matrix

Goal → season.

Pick your goal in the left column. The right two columns tell you which season best fits and why.

Your goal
Pick this
Why
I want the biggest bull (trophy hunt)
Rifle 3rd (mid-November)
Cold-driven dark-timber concentration. Bulls in dark timber feel safe and move on predictable patterns. Historical highest-success rifle window for trophy-class bulls.
I want the highest probability of any bull
Rifle 3rd or 2nd
Both run 70–85% success on private-land outfitter operations. Pick based on weather tolerance.
I want intimate close-range encounters
Archery (September)
Bulls bugle into cow calls. 30–50 yard setups. The drama of the rut is unique to September.
I want low hunter pressure
Muzzleloader (mid-Sept) or rifle 4th
Both have the smallest applicant pools. Muzzleloader trades pressure for ranging difficulty; rifle 4th trades pressure for cold.
I want the most predictable weather
Rifle 1st (mid-October)
Pre-storm window. Cool but not yet sub-zero. The country is reliable.
I want a hunt with my non-hunting partner
Rifle 2nd (late October)
Most outfitter-side family-week programming runs in this window. Most polished operation across non-hunter programming.
I want the cheapest hunt week
Rifle 4th (limited)
Shorter window = less guide time = often slightly lower outfitter pricing. Plus the lowest tag-fee component since rifle 4th tags are easier to acquire.

Season-by-season

All six seasons, in their own words.

Archery · September

Pressure · Low

Best for
Bull bugles + rut hunting
Avoid if
You're sensitive to weather variability
Success rate (private land)
55–70%
Temperature range
35–75°F

Pick it because: Peak rut window. Bulls bugling, intimate setups, 30–50 yard shots. Highest single-day excitement of the elk season; weather is mild and the country is at its prettiest.

Skip it because: Late September can deliver snow, heavy rain, or 80°F sun. Thermals shift constantly. If you want predictable hunting conditions, archery isn't it.

Muzzleloader · Mid-September

Pressure · Lowest of fall

Best for
Late-rut shoulder, less pressure
Avoid if
Your eyes can't shoot iron sights at 200 yards
Success rate (private land)
60–75%
Temperature range
28–68°F

Pick it because: Quieter than archery — most archery hunters have left, rifle hunters haven't arrived. The last week of bugling on a Colorado elk season. 100–200 yard shots with iron sights only.

Skip it because: Iron-sight ranging is genuinely harder than scoped shooting. If you haven't practiced unscoped at 150-200 yards, the field shots can frustrate.

Rifle 1st · Mid-October

Pressure · Low

Best for
Bull-only limited entry, smaller crowds
Avoid if
You wanted combined deer + elk
Success rate (private land)
55–70%
Temperature range
20–55°F

Pick it because: 5-day bull-only window. The smallest hunter pool of the rifle seasons. Bulls have come off the rut, the rut signs are still everywhere, and the weather is the most predictable of the rifle months.

Skip it because: Only 5 days. No deer combo. If you want a longer window or a combined tag, look at rifle 2nd or 3rd.

Rifle 2nd · Late October

Pressure · Moderate

Best for
Combined deer + elk, balanced weather
Avoid if
You want absolute lowest pressure
Success rate (private land)
65–80% (private land)
Temperature range
15–50°F

Pick it because: The most-applied-for elk season on most Colorado units. 9-day combined deer-and-elk window. Solid weather (still pre-storm-season most years), reliable post-rut feeding patterns, and the most productive single-week elk hunt at most outfitters.

Skip it because: Higher hunter density than the other rifle seasons. If you're hunting public land, expect to encounter other hunters.

Rifle 3rd · Mid-November

Pressure · Moderate

Best for
Trophy bulls in dark timber, cold-weather hunting
Avoid if
You don't handle cold well
Success rate (private land)
70–85% (private land)
Temperature range
5–40°F

Pick it because: Historically the highest-fill-rate rifle season on most private-land ranches including GMU 59. The cold push compresses bulls into dark timber pockets and exposes movement patterns. Snow tracks make the country honest.

Skip it because: Real cold. 5°F at first light is normal. Real snow. If you don't have boots rated to 0°F and the layering system for cold-weather glassing, this is the wrong week.

Rifle 4th · Late November

Pressure · Lowest of fall

Best for
Late-snow tracking, smallest hunter pool
Avoid if
You can't take 5°F for a week
Success rate (private land)
55–75%
Temperature range
0–35°F

Pick it because: 5-day late-snow tracking hunt. Smallest pool of any rifle season. Fresh snow + bull tracks + the right wind direction = textbook hunt. If you draw it, you'll have country to yourself.

Skip it because: Real severe weather windows. The cold is now sub-zero capable. Some hunters love it; others find it brutal. Honest with yourself about your tolerance.

Frequently asked.

What's the best time to hunt elk in Colorado?

It depends on your goal. For trophy bulls, mid-November rifle 3rd (cold-driven dark-timber concentration). For peak excitement, September archery (rut and bugles). For highest success rate, rifle 2nd or 3rd on private-land outfitter operations (70–85%). For lowest hunter pressure, muzzleloader or rifle 4th.

When is the Colorado elk rut?

The Colorado elk rut peaks September 15–25 across most units. Bulls bugle most aggressively the second and third weeks of September; the rut tail extends into early October on the cooler high-elevation units. September archery is the only Colorado weapon class that overlaps the rut peak; muzzleloader hits the late-rut shoulder.

What's the most popular Colorado elk season?

Rifle 2nd (late October) is the most-applied-for Colorado elk season — 9 days, combined deer-and-elk, post-rut feeding patterns, manageable weather. Highest applicant pool, longest hunt window, broadest appeal across hunter experience levels.

Which Colorado rifle elk season has the best success rate?

On private-land outfitter operations, rifle 3rd (mid-November) historically delivers the highest fill rate — typically 70–85%. The cold pushes elk into dark timber where they're predictable. On public-land hunts, rifle 2nd often slightly outperforms rifle 3rd because of better weather access.

Is November too late to hunt elk in Colorado?

No — November is when several of the most productive Colorado rifle seasons fall. Rifle 3rd (mid-November) is the highest-success private-land window. Rifle 4th (late November) is the smallest-pool late-snow tracking hunt. Weather demands cold-rated gear but the country and the animals reward it.

What month is best for archery elk in Colorado?

September. Colorado archery elk runs early September through late September; the rut peaks September 15–25. Most archery hunters target the second and third weeks of the season to maximize bugling activity and bull responsiveness to calling.

Pick your season

Tell us your goal. We’ll book the week.

Send your goal (trophy / high success / low pressure / rut intimacy / cold tolerance) and we’ll match you to the season that delivers it on GMU 59.

Plan a huntGet a quote

From the journal

Field notes you might like.

See more →